Each week, a new batch of CRUMBL cookie flavors drops, ranging from classic chocolate chips to new creations like cornbread and even cake cookies. Some people drive for hours just to get Crumbl, but is it really worth the money you’re spending?

Last week, I bought four Crumbl cookies to taste and rate. I tasted the peanut butter cup (featuring Reese’s peanut butter cups), vanilla crumb cake cookie (featuring Golden Oreos), confetti and chocolate cookies and cream. For all four cookies, it cost me $18.49.

The first cookie I tried was a peanut butter cup, which was my favorite because I love Reese’s cups. I gave that cookie an 8/10. It was really good. There was a perfect amount of chocolate and peanut butter, so overall it was pretty good.

Next up is the confetti cookie. I give that cookie a 6/10. It was okay. It wasn’t my favorite. I feel like it needed confetti frosting or something. I thought it was bland.

I then tasted the vanilla crumb cake cookie. I really liked that cookie. I’d rate it like a 7.5/10. The cookie was good, but it was a little too sweet for me. The flavors were really good. I liked the cream cheese frosting.

Last but not least, I tried the chocolate cookies and cream. I rated that 8/10. It was pretty good, and it was really moist. I feel like this one also would have been better if it had cookies and cream flavored frosting.

Overall, I feel like the price isn’t terrible because you’re paying like $4 per cookie, which isn’t bad for four decent-sized cookies. I wouldn’t recommend going every week, but it’s worth it for an occasional treat.